25 Oct Executive Condominiums Performance
The Executive Condominium Option
Recently, I met up with a young couple to discuss their possible next housing move.
Their current HDB BTO flat (build to order flats are brand new flats bought directly from HDB) will be achieving its 5-years MOP (minimum occupation period) in a couple of months time and they wanted to get my inputs on the various residential properties options that are available to them.
Getting a brand new executive condominium was one of the options we discussed.
If you are already familiar with what executive condominiums are, please click to jump to the section on executive condominiums performance.
If you are not sure what an executive condominium is, please read on.
What is an executive condominium?
Executive condominiums are a form of unique hybrid public housing that is governed by the Executive Condominium Housing Act & Executive Condominium Housing Scheme Regulations.
It is unique in the sense that it starts off as a form of public housing supervised by the Housing and Development Board before before eventually becoming a private property. See section on rules below.
On the outside (& inside actually), an executive condominium looks exactly like a private condominium.
An executive condominium is gated and comes with facilities that are commonly found in a private condominium.
Executive condominiums only sit on 99-years leasehold land parcels, which is one of the more common land tenures for private condominiums.
Like private condominiums, the owners of executive condominiums have the option (10 years after TOP) to opt for a collective sale (en bloc sale) as a form of exit strategy further down the road as the buildings start to age.
They are also built by private developers.
The similarities end here.
What are the rules for executive condominiums?
These are the rules that are unique to the executive condominiums compared to private condominiums.
✅ Only Singaporeans (various forms of family nucleus) can purchase a brand new executive condominium under one of the following schemes – public scheme, fiance/fiancee scheme, orphans scheme, joint singles scheme.
✅ A married couple must be of the pairing Singaporean/Singaporean or Singaporean/Singapore Permanent Resident in order to be eligible to purchase.
✅ Only buyers with a combined household income of less than $16k (subject to change) are allowed to buy.
✅ Buyers of brand new executive condominiums are only allowed to sell after the executive condominiums turn 5 years old (from TOP date).
✅ Executive condominiums can be rented out only after crossing the 5 years old mark.
✅ Between the 5 and 10 years mark, the executive condominiums can only be sold to Singaporeans or Singapore permanent residents.
✅ After the 10 years mark, the executive condominium will become a full-fledged private condominium and foreigners would be eligible to purchase.
✅ The mortgage servicing ratio (MSR) & total debt servicing ratio (TDSR) are used to determine how much a buyer of a brand new executive condominium can borrow.
✅ Resale levy may be payable for certain buyers of executive condominiums.
Please visit the HDB website for the latest rules that are applicable for the purchase of executive condominiums.
Why buy brand new executive condominiums?
So many rules… why would a buyer want to buy an executive condominium then?
Why not consider other residential properties?
The answer lies in the attractive sale price during the initial sales launch.
Executive condominiums sit on land parcels that are sold at a subsidised rate by the government.
Hence they are priced cheaper than comparable private condominiums during the initial sales launch.
Besides a lower entry price, they also offer a very good chance of capital appreciation which I will touch on in the next section.
In addition, a couple who currently owns a HDB can purchase a brand new under construction executive condominium first (need to pay downpayment) without having to incur additional buyer stamp duty (ABSD). If their finances allow them to, they can continue to stay in the HDB and sell it closer to the date when the construction of the executive condominium is completed.
And as a side bonus, certain buyers of executive condominiums may be eligible for CPF housing grants.
Performance of Executive Condominiums
The young couple was curious about the resale performance of the executive condominiums and so I gathered a set of transaction data to share with them.
Executive Condominiums Transactions Dataset
I selected the last 15 executive condominiums to hit the 5 years MOP mark and pulled out their price movement and resale transactions (up to 3rd quarter of 2020) to see how they performed.
Among the transactions pulled out were a couple of units that were sold before the 5 years MOP was up.
This group of sellers probably had to sell because of special circumstances and received permission by HDB to do so.
And they are typically the ones that achieved the lowest gain.
This is a quick summary of how these 15 executive condominiums performed.
Profitability of Executive Condominiums
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Executive Condo
Volume
% Made Money
Highest Gain
Lowest Gain
Please take note that the gains stated above & what you will see further below do not take into consideration expenses like stamp duty, legal fee and agent fees.
Some observations
All the resale transactions for these executive condominiums up to the end of 3rd quarter 2020 were profitable except for one sole transaction in Watercolours that incurred a loss of $31,300.
For the units that etched out a gain, the question is – how much did they gain?
📌 The highest gain achieved was for a unit at Esparina Residences that sold for a gain of $651,000. The total holding period was slightly under 8 years.
📌 Out of a total of 1,103 recorded transactions, 231 transactions achieved a gain of at least $300,000. Which works out to be about 1 in every 5 transactions.
📌 A total of 63 transactions achieved a gain of at least $400,000.
📌 The highest price appreciation in terms of percentage gain came in at 67%.
📌 Heron Bay and Waterwoods have a very limited number of transactions because a large number of the units there have just hit the 5 years mark.
In the next section, you will be able to see the top 30 transactions for each of these executive condominiums sorted by profits. Heron Bay & Waterwoods have been excluded.
Breakdown of the resale transactions
1) 1 Canberra Price Chart & Resale Transactions
2) Arc at Tampines Price Chart & Resale Transactions
3) Austville Residences Price Chart & Resale Transactions
4) Belysa Price Chart & Resale Transactions
5) Blossom Residences Price Chart & Resale Transactions
6) Esparina Residences Price Chart & Resale Transactions
7) Prive Price Chart & Resale Transactions
8) Riverparc Residence Price Chart & Resale Transactions
9) Tampines Trilliant Price Chart & Resale Transactions
10) The Canopy Price Chart & Resale Transactions
11) The Rainforest Price Chart & Resale Transactions
12) Twin Waterfalls Price Chart & Resale Transactions
13) Watercolours Price Chart & Resale Transactions
Closing Points on Executive Condominiums
As can be seen from the most recent resale transaction stats above, executive condominiums have performed well in recent years.
This can mainly be attributed to the fact that the land cost is subsidised for executive condominiums.
Although the gains achieved seem fairly good, it must be noted that there is no 100% guarantee that subsequent buyers of new executive condominiums will be able to see such healthy gains.
But the chances of them seeing gains should still be good because of the land cost component.
With all that has been said, is going the executive condominium route always the best possible option?
The answer is, it depends.
It depends on the buyer’s situation, needs and objectives.
What factors should the buyer be considering?
What should the buyer be aware of?
Under what circumstances should a buyer not go for an executive condominium?
Get in touch with me today and let me help you assess if going the executive condominium route is the most appropriate for you.